Acupuncture is a potentially cheap and safe form of treatment for relieving some types of pain,
Acupuncture is a potentially cheap and safe form of treatment for relieving some types of pain, yet many doctors in the West remain sceptical of its value. They find the ancient Chinese concepts of traditional acupuncture and its claim to be a treat ment for all ills unacceptable, but these concepts may be largely irrelevant to the practice of effective analgesic acu puncture. Sceptics suggest that acupuncture may be nothing more than a powerful placebo. If, however, acupuncture exerts some specific analgesic effect like other physical treatments, this is not amenable to proof by formal clinical trial. Acu puncture may be performed in several ways, including manual rotation of the needles and low-frequency or high-frequency electrical stimulation .through them. No truly double-blind comparison can be made with alternative treatments since the needles must be inserted in the conscious patient. Despite the scepticism, however, evidence is accumulating about its mechanisms of action.
The possibility that acupuncture analgesia is mediated by a humoral factor was first suggested by a report that transfer of cerebrospinal fluid from rabbits having acupuncture produces analgesia in recipient rabbits.1 The time course of analgesia is similar whether induced by acupuncture or by stimulation of the brainstem periaqueductal grey matter, both forms of stimulation producing effects with a delayed beginning and end.2 Analgesia induced by stimulating neurones of the periaqueductal grey matter appears to be mediated by endo genous opiate-like peptides,3 so perhaps analgesia after acupuncture is produced by the release of similar endogenous substances.
The endogenous peptides with opiate-like analgesic effects are broadly classed as enkephalins and endorphins. Research into the role of these opioids in acupuncture analgesia falls into into two main categories: firstly, the use of drugs modifying opiate action and, secondly, the measurement of opioid peptide concentrations in blood and cerebrospinal fluid. The specific opiate-receptor-blocking drug naloxone reduces or abolishes low-frequency (2-6 Hz) electroacupuncture analgesia in various animals subjected to pain.4-7 Naloxone has no effect, however, on the analgesia induced by high-frequency (200 Hz) electroacupuncture in mice.4 The degree of analgesia in these studies was assessed by behavioural measurements,4-5 by the depression of the firing rate of pain-transmitting (nociceptive) spinal neurones,6 or by changes in pain-induced cortical evoked potentials.7 In human subjects with chronic or experi mental pain all but one group of workers report that naloxone reduces the analgesia produced by manual acupuncture or low-frequency electroacupuncture via needles or surface electrodes.28-10
Certain D-amino-acids inhibit the peptidases that otherwise rapidly degrade the endorphins, thus limiting the duration of their effects. These D-amino-acids enhance the effect of low-frequency electroacupuncture in mice, the resulting analgesia being reversible by naloxone.11 Mice of the inbred strain CXBK have a low density of opiate receptors in the brain and achieve little analgesia after morphine or acupuncture.12 In contrast, the related group of C57BL mice, which have a normal density of brain opiate receptors, respond to acupuncture and morphine with normal analgesia. This evidence further supports a role for endogenous opioid peptides in acupuncture analgesia.
Some recent evidence points to the release of opioid peptides in cerebrospinal fluid during acupuncture analgesia. Several workers have shown an increase in opiate-like activity in the cerebrospinal fluid of animals and man during acupuncture, 13 but this was measured by a radioreccptor assay that lacked specificity and did not identify structurally discrete peptides. Clement-Jones et al16 18 measured cerebrospinal concentrations of beta-endorphin and met-enkephalin by radioimmunoassay in two groups of patients before and after 30 minutes of electroacupuncture. They used a highly specific met-enkephalin assay that had insignificant cross-reaction with other peptides.16 A group of patients with recurrent pain received low-frequency electroacupuncture. Concentrations of met-enkephalin in the cerebrospinal fluid were unchanged but those of beta-endorphin rose after electro-acupuncture.17 In a second study, in heroin addicts who were being withdrawn from their drugs, high-frequency electro-acupuncture was given to suppress the symptoms and signs of withdrawal. Clinically the treatment was highly effective and it was associated with a rise in met-enkephalin concentrations, which had been low before treatment; beta-endorphin concentrations, which were raised initially, did not change after electroacupuncture.18 The difference between the effects on beta-endorphin and met-enkephalin may be due to the different conditions being treated, but more probably relate simply to the frequencies of the stimuli. Thus low-frequency electroacupuncture releases beta-endorphin, whose effects can be blocked, at least in part, by naloxone; whereas high-frequency electroacupuncture may release met-enkephalin, whose effects are not blocked by conventional doses of naloxone.
Information about changes in opioids in blood during acupuncture is more confused. The results of two studies suggest that circulating immunoreactive beta-endorphin rises during electroacupuncture,19-20 but stress was not excluded as a cause of the changes. Beta-endorphin is released from the pituitary in parallel with adrenocorticotrophic hormone and the lipo-trophins during stress and indeed all other known stimuli. Other workers have reported a fall in plasma adrenocorticotrophic hormone as well as beta-endorphin and cortisol concentrations during electroacupuncture,18-21 an effect compatible with the central release of enkephalins.22-23 In any event, beta-endorphin released into the blood is unlikely 10 mediate the central analgesia induced by acupuncture, since this peptide penetrates poorly into the central nervous system. Pomeranz et al found that hypophysectomy blunted the analgesic response to low-frequency electroacupuncture,24 but this has not been confirmed. In man the pituitary is probably not an important source of cerebral beta-endorphin, since the concentrations in the cerebrospinal fluid are normal in patients with panhypopituitarism, who have undetectable plasma concentrations of beta-endorphin.25
5-Hydroxytryptamine (serotonin) probably plays an important part in mediating the analgesic effect of acupuncture.26-28 The tryptophan hydroxylase inhibitor para-chlorphenylalanine decreases concentrations in the brain of 5-hydroxytryptamine but works in the opposite way to naloxone, reducing the analgesic effect of high-frequency electroacupuncture in mice but having no effect on low-frequency electroacupuncture analgesia.4 Other neurotrans-mitter systems may mediate some effects of acupuncture but so far their role is uncertain.28-29
The effects of low-frequency electroacupuncture and manual acupuncture may be mediated, at least in part, by stimulation of beta-endorphin-containing neurones of the peri-aqueductal grey matter, thereby activating endogenous pain-control pathways. An important 5-hydroxytryptamine-contain-ing pathway that inhibits pain arises in the nucleus raphe magnus in the medulla and projects to the spinal dorsal horns. Stimulation of this serotoninergic system activates inhibitory enkephalinergic interneurones situated in the spinal dorsal horns, which in turn inhibit the activity of nociceptive neurones in the dorsal horns.30 Possibly high-frequency electroacupuncture has an effect in activating this serotonin-ergic-enkephalinergic system.
Can we now assert that acupuncture is more than a placebo ? This question seems no longer relevant, since the relief of pain associated with placebos is probably also mediated by release of endogenous opioids and can be blocked by naloxone.31 Perhaps the evidence that different forms of acupuncture elicit specific neurohumoral effects to produce analgesia in animals and man gives acupuncture some physiological respectability. In any event, if acupuncture provides effective and safe pain relief then its mechanism of action is of secondary importance. The most fruitful result of research into the neurochemical basis of acupuncture may be the discovery of a means of increasing cerebral release of specific opiate-like peptides and other neurotransmitters. This may be useful for investigating and treating pain and perhaps also some neurological, psychiatric, and neuroendocrine diseases.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1506864/?page=1
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1506864/pdf/bmjcred00677-0006.pdf
References
1 Research Group of Acupuncture Anaesthesia, Peking. The role of some neurotransmitters of brain in finger-acupuncture analgesia. Sci Sin 1974; 17:112-30.
2Mayer DJ, Price DD, Rafii A. Antagonism of acupuncture analgesia in man by the narcotic antagonist naloxone. Brain Res 1977;121:368 72.
3 Hosobuchi Y, Rossier J, Bloom FE, Guillemin R. Stimulation of human pariaqueductal gray for pain relief increases immunoreactive (3-endorphin in ventricular fluid. Science 1979;203:279-81. ‘
4 Cheng RS, Pomeranz B. Electroacupuncture analgesia could be mediated by at least two pain-relieving mechanisms: endorphin and non-endorphin systems. Life Sci 1979;25:1957-62.
5 Fu T-C, Halenda SP, Dewcy WL. The effect of hypophysectomy on acupuncture analgesia in the mouse. Brain Res 1980;202 : 33-9.
6 Pomeranz B, Cheng R. Suppression of noxious responses in single neurons of cat spinal cord by electroacupuncture and its reversal by the opiate antagonist naloxone. Exp Neural 1979;64:327-41.
7 Jieshi C, Zhijin Y, Shupei O. The effect of naloxone on the inhibitory action of electroacupuncture upon cortical potentials evoked by tooth pulp stimulation in rabbits. In: National symposium of acupuncture and moxibustion and acupuncture anaesthesia. BeijingvChina: World Books 1979 : 482.
8 Chapman CR, Benedetti C. Analgesia following transcutaneous electrical stimulation and its partial reversal by a narcotic antagonist. Life Sci 1977; 21:1645-8.
9 Sjolund BH, Eriksson MB. The influence of naloxone on analgesia produced by peripheral conditioning stimulation. Brain Res 1979;173-295-301.
10 Chapman CR, Colpitts YM, Benedetti C, Kitaeff R, Gehrig JD. Evoked potential assessment of acupunctural analgesia: attempted reversal with naloxone. Pain 1980 ;9:183-97.
11 Cheng RS, Pomeranz B. A combined treatment with D-amino acids and electroacupuncture produces a greater analgesia than either treatment alone; naloxone reverses these effects. Pain 1980;8:231-6.
12 Peets JM, Pomeranz B. CXBK mice deficient in opiate receptors show poor electroacupuncture analgesia. Nature 1978; 273:675-6.
13 Gang Z, Shixiang W, Fangsheng W, et al. Increased levels of endorphins in the cisternal cerebrospinal fluid of rabbits in acupuncture analgesia. In: National symposium of acupuncture and moxibustion and acupuncture anaesthesia. Beijing, China: World Books, 1979:447.
14 Sjolund B, Terenius L, Eriksson M. Increased cerebrospinal fluid levels of endorphins after electroacupuncture. Acta Physiol Scand 1977;100: 382-4.
15 Xiaoping P, Xianhong L, Suying Y, et al. The relationship etween the human CSF levels of endorphins and acupuncture analgesia. In: National symposium of acupuncture and moxibustion and acupuncture anaesthesia. Beijing, China: World Books, 1979:479-80.
16 Clement-Jones V, Lowry PJ, Rees LH, Besser GM. Development of a specific extracted radioimmunoassay for methionine enkephalin in human plasma and cerebrospinal fluid. J Endocrinol 1980;86:231-43.
17 Clement-Jones V, Tomlin S, Rees LH, McLoughlin L, Besser GM, Wen HL. Increased p-endorphin but not met-enkephalin levels in human cerebrospinal fluid after acupuncture for recurrent pain. Lancet 1980;ii: 946-8, 9.
18 Clement-Jones V, Lowry PJ, McLoughlin L, Besser GM, Rees LH, Wen HL. Acupuncture in heroin addicts: changes in met-enkephalin and (3-endorphin in blood and cerebrospinal fluid. Lancet 1979;ii:380-2, 3.
19 Malizia E, Andreucci G, Paoluci D, Crescenzi F, Fabbri A, Fraioli F. Electroacupuncture and peripheral |3 endorphin and ACTH levels. Lancet 1979;ii:535-6.
20 Abbate D, Santamaria A, Brambilla A, Panerai AE, Di Giulio AM. (3-Endorphin and electroacupuncture. Lancet 1980;ii:1309.
21 Wen HL, Ng YH, Ho WKK, et al. Acupuncture in narcotic withdrawal: a preliminary report on biochemical changes in the blood and urine of heroin addicts. Bull Narc 1978;30,2:31-9.
22 Stubbs WA, Delitala G, Jones A, et al. Hormonal and metabolic responses to an enkephalin analogue in normal man. Lancet 1978;ii:1225-7.
23 Gaillard RC, Grossman A, Smith R, Rees LH, Besser GM. The effects of a met-enkephalin analogue on ACTH, P-LPH, (3-endorphin and met-enkephalin in patients with adrenocortical disease. Clin Endocrinol 1981; 14:471-8.
24 Pomeranz B, Cheng R, Law P. Acupuncture reduces electrophysiological and behavioural responses to noxious stimuli: pituitary is implicated. Exp Neural 1977;54:172-8.
25Jeffcoate WJ, McLoughlin L, Hope J, et al. (3-Endorphin in human cerebrospinal fluid. Lancet 1978;ii:l 19-21.
26 Chi-Sheng H, Pao-Ho C, Chen-Chy L, Lian-Hua L, Tsung-Hsien Y, Min-Feng J. The role of central 5-hydroxytryptamine in acupuncture analgesia. Sci Sin 1979;22.-91-104.
27 Ching-Cheng Y, Ta-Hsien L, Shih-Hsiang W, Kang T. A study on the release of 3H-5-hydroxytryptamine from brain during acupuncture and morphine analgesia. Sci Sin 1977;20:113-24.
28 McLennan H, Gilfillan K, Heap Y. Some pharmacological observations on the analgesia induced by acupuncture in rabbits. Pain 1977 ;3:229-38.
29 Jisheng H, Minfeng Re, Jian T, Shaoguang F, Jinmin X, Xinmin G. The role of central catecholamine in acupuncture analgesia. Chin MedJ 1979; 92:793-800.
30 Basbaum Al, Fields HL. Endogenous pain control mechanisms: review and hypothesis. Ann Neural 1978;iv:451-62.
31 Levine JD, Gordon NC, Fields HL. The mechanism of placebo analgesia. Lancet 1978;ii:654-7.